Are you more like Dobby or Jeeves when you serve?Let me explain.
One of my subs told me that he had believed that slaves cannot think for themselves. They're mindless drones who do everything at the beck and call of a Master.
I'll admit, for about a week when I first starting getting into this world, I enjoyed choosing what slaves would wear or what they'd eat. Rapidly, though, I realised I didn't care. I was putting effort and time into thinking about something that had no relation to my life. If a slave isn't near me, why do I give a flying fuck about what colour t-shirt he's wearing?
Rules are ok, and can be useful for longer term goals. Restricted diets to improve health; certain types of clothing to remind the sub that he's owned; enforced chastity. But that's about training the mind, it's again not about making the sub useful.
How much, then can a sub think?Let's examine for a moment two types of slave from not-quite-great literature. The house elf (Harry Potter) and Jeeves (Jeeves and Wooster).
Dobby and the other house elves are true slaves. They are bound to do all that their owners command. They cannot think outside the commands. They are given strict rules.They're true lowlives. In BDSM, they're more like gimps. They hang around doing very little. Maybe they're bound. Maybe they're told to sit in the corner. Maybe they're ignored.
I remember meeting a guy who I had fancied for ages, and spent an evening at his place. He asked to be caged. So I caged him. At which point I thought "What next?" I went and watched TV for an hour. He might have been getting something out of it, but I didn't really.
Likewise, recently a slave came round and I told him to sit at the end of my bed with a mask on. He had told me he liked to be ignored. So I ignored him for a while, but it was very much like having an elephant in the room. I couldn't really do the stuff I wanted to do as I was aware that there was human sitting there waiting for something to happen. Eventually I pissed all over him and fucked his mouth. Both of which I enjoyed.
Maybe I'm a selfish dom, but Dobbies really don't do a lot for me. It feels like I have to do all the thinking and they get bossed around and turned on by that.
On the other hand, we have Jeeves, the butler.
Anyone who's read the books or has seen the Fry and Laurie adaptation will know that in this case, Jeeves was the servant to the slightly useless Wooster. Often, it was Jeeves' quick thinking that got Wooster out of trouble. Jeeves was free to walk away, but stayed due to genuine affection and a desire to make his Master's life better.
I would prefer a proactive sub any day. I give orders, and set rules, but I want a sub who can think between the lines. "Bring a jock strap and harness." - the sub brings boots as well, realising they'll be useful. "Find a flight from a to b on day x." The sub checks alternative routes and dates for the best options, lays them out and asks me to make a final decision.
Every now and then, this means that the sub goes beyond his remit and does something I haven't asked him to do. But the rub is - I didn't tell him not to do it. So it's my fault. I explain how I'd like it to be done in the future and we move on. There's no need for punishment as I know the sub is already beating himself up about not interpreting my requirements correctly.
So to all those doms out there who tell subs they can't think: you're missing out on a much more useful sub.
For all those subs out there who don't feel right being told not to think: find a dom who appreciates what he can get out of you.


